Most "is this backlink any good?" advice stops at rel="nofollow" . I went through what rel actually says on editorial and directory pages last week, so this time I wanted the other stuff: the checks that can quietly cancel a link even when the anchor tag looks perfect.
So this morning I pointed a small Node script at 48 pages on 10 sites I run:
22 product pages on my launch sites and directory (Aura++, EarlyHunt, IndieHunt, MakerHunt, SideHunt, Uno Directory)
22 pages on my four small press sites (14 published articles, 8 project pages)
4 of the Markdown copies those press sites publish next to each article
These are the kind of pages people submit to, or pay for, to get a link. They're mine, so I can poke at them all I want and tell you what's broken without pointing at anyone else's site.
Checked Monday 9 Nov 2026, between 10:54 and 11:14 IST. Four full runs, two with Googlebot's user agent string and two with a Chrome one.…