Workflow vs Agent: Deterministic Orchestration & Dynamic Tool Selection
Quick Diagnosis
Situation Recommended approach Why it fits
All steps known ahead of time (e.g., fetch data → prompt → parse → store) Workflow Immutable execution, easy testing, predictable token usage
Path depends on content or user intent (e.g., “answer any compliance question”) Agent Chooses tools at runtime, handles unknown sub‑tasks
Regulatory audit required (immutable logs, version‑controlled prompts) Workflow Deterministic runs produce repeatable audit trails
Live numeric value needed (credit score, market rate) Tool call from workflow (authoritative API) Guarantees freshness; does not rely on stale retrieval
Batch processing with tight cost budget Workflow One LLM call per step, predictable token usage
Real‑time, ad‑hoc question answering Agent Dynamic reasoning, on‑the‑fly tool selection
Mix of known skeleton + occasional live‑value request Hybrid (workflow + runtime API/agent) Keeps core deterministic, adds flexibility…