It's pretty common for someone to ask how to manage a losing credit spread. Hell, that's been me as recently as checks watch today. But I digress
Setup: 25-delta put credit spreads, 30-45 DTE, QQQ with a 5% wing and TQQQ with a 10% wing. Real end-of-day bid/ask from April 2022 on, fees included, and an early close pays fees on two more legs. 42 to 396 trades depending on the cell. Exits: take profit at 25/50/75% of the credit, close at 21 DTE, or hold to expiry.
What came out:
Holding made the most money in almost every cell. The one exception was 75% take profit on the biggest QQQ cell, and it won by a few bucks a trade, basically noise. 50% take profit gave up 13% to 55% of the total, depending on the cell.
Closing at 21 DTE was the worst. It lost money on both TQQQ cells while holding made money on both. On the big QQQ cell, it kept about a quarter of what holding made. The worst trade was the same under every rule except 21 DTE. The losses that hurt were gaps through both strikes.…