While nobody denies that the New York Islanders have a storied history, nobody can deny that the franchise's future is very much centered around budding star Matthew Schaefer.

After being drafted No. 1 overall in 2025, it's become quite clear that Schaefer has become one of the most recognizable faces for the Islanders. Bo Horvat was named the Isles' 16th captain in franchise history back in September — with Horvat filling the vacancy left by Anders Lee, who joined the Utah Mammoth for a three-year, $16.2-million contract.

Schaefer would go on to be added as an alternate captain for the New York organization this year alongside Brayden Schenn, joining Kyle Palmieri and Ryan Pulock in wearing the "A."

That begs the question: Is Schaefer next up for the captaincy?

Matthew Schaefer Ready to Wait for Added Leadership Role

New York Islanders defenseman Matthew Schaefer Credit: John E.…