I needed to pick a Claude model for production.
Three options. Three price points. Three levels of capability.
So I tested them against real code. Not benchmarks. Real problems.
The Quick Numbers
Opus 5.5:
12 seconds response time
$0.042 per request
95% accuracy
Exceptional depth
Sonnet 5.5:
9 seconds response time
$0.011 per request
90% accuracy
Practical recommendations
Haiku 5.5:
4 seconds response time
$0.001 per request
80% accuracy
Surface-level but useful
The Uncomfortable Truth
At scale (10,000 requests/day):
Opus: $420/day ($153K/year)
Sonnet: $110/day ($40K/year)
Haiku: $10/day ($3.6K/year)
Most developers default to Opus because "it's the best."
But they're throwing away money.
What I Actually Found
Opus wins on ~10% of tasks: multi-step reasoning, complex refactoring, novel problems.
For everything else? Sonnet crushes it. Cheaper, faster, good enough.
And Haiku? The benchmarks undersell it.β¦