TL;DR: The checkout flow test passes on your machine, passes in your demo to the team, and then fails at 3am in CI every single day for two weeks. You dig into the logs and find a different failure mode each time — sometimes it's a missing element, sometimes a timeout, sometimes the te

📖 Reading time: ~36 min

What's in this article

The Real Problem With Recorded Tests

The Tools I've Actually Run in Production (My Current Stack)

Playwright Codegen: What I Actually Use Day-to-Day

Cypress Studio: Good Idea, Inconsistent Execution

Selenium IDE: The One You're Probably Stuck With

TestCafe Studio: The Underdog Worth Knowing About

Head-to-Head Comparison Table

When to Pick What: Match the Tool to Your Situation

The Real Problem With Recorded Tests

The checkout flow test passes on your machine, passes in your demo to the team, and then fails at 3am in CI every single day for two weeks.…