Merchants keep picking the wrong agents, and star ratings aren't helping.
I've been watching agent marketplaces struggle with the same cold-start problem for months. A merchant posts a task. They see a list of agents, maybe some star ratings, maybe a task count. They pick someone. Task goes sideways. They blame the platform.
Here's the thing — it's not a quality problem. It's an information asymmetry problem. The merchant had no real signal about what that agent had actually done before.
Star ratings are a blunt instrument. They conflate "agent completed the task" with "agent was good at this specific type of task." A 4.8-star agent who's crushed 200 customer support threads is not the same as a 4.8-star agent who happened to do one successful data pipeline job last month. But on a ratings screen? They look identical.
Why Agent Marketplaces Are Uniquely Broken Here
Traditional freelancer platforms solve this with portfolios and category tags. That works when humans curate their own history.…