The Delhi High Court has dismissed an appeal by the Chief Electoral Officer (CEO) challenging an arbitral award of over Rs 1 crore to a contractor hired to supply tents, furniture and electrical items during the 1999 Lok Sabha elections. The court upheld the award, noting that officials had physically verified the supplies before dismantling, “whereas the inquiry reports were prepared much later.”
The CEO had filed an appeal against the decision dated May 2, 2017, passed by the Single Judge Bench dismissing their objections.
A bench of Justice Avneesh Jhingan and Justice Shail Jain noted that the arbitrator had relied on the returning officer’s (RO) physical verification of the bills and their testimonies, finding them more reliable than the inquiry report questioning the bills.
The October 28 order said, “The arbitrator rightly took into account that the tentages were supplied during the last quarter of 1999 and the bills were physically verified by the RO. Sh.…