Ask three people in the same company for the win rate and you can get three answers, all calculated correctly, from the same CRM. The numerator is never the argument. Everyone agrees on what a won deal is. The fight is about the denominator: which deals count as a chance you had to win.
That choice can move the number by half. It can also make a quarter look like a disaster when nothing about the sales team changed. Here's a simulated example, the three common formulas, and the one I'd put in front of a leadership team.
The setup
I simulated two years of opportunities, about 9,000 of them. The rules never change:
30% are disqualified on the first call and closed lost within ten days.
12% are qualified, then go quiet. Nobody closes them out. They sit open.
The rest get worked.…