Spend five minutes in any trading Discord and you'll see some version of these: "market makers hunt the liquidity", "they ate the wall, breakout incoming", "wall got pulled, it's a spoof, short it". People sell courses on this stuff. There are paid channels and whole "order-flow academies" built around it.
I've never seen one of them show actual statistics. A screenshot of a good trade, sure. A count with a control group, never.
We run a crypto trading platform and a free order-book heatmap . Yes, it's ours, and I'll come back to why that matters at the end. Before we drew any "magnets" or "strong levels" on that chart, we wanted to know if any of this holds up. So we recorded the Bybit book once a minute, wrote each test down before running it (so we couldn't quietly change the rules after seeing the result), and ran them.
It didn't go well for the order-book folklore. None of the 7 liquidity beliefs we tested held up.…