1. Preliminaries
1.1 Ordinary versus Global Manipulation
Manipulative tactics like those listed above are commonplace in ordinary life. This distinguishes them from forms of influence described as “manipulation” in the free will literature. There, the term “manipulation” typically refers to radical programming or reprogramming of all or most of an agent’s mental states. Such global manipulation (as we might call it) is also typically imagined as happening via extra-ordinary methods, such as supernatural intervention, direct neurological engineering, or radical programs of indoctrination or brainwashing. Global manipulation is typically thought to deprive its victim of free will. This common intuition drives the “manipulation argument”, which seeks to defend incompatibilism by claiming that living in a deterministic universe is analogous to being the victim of global manipulation.…