Menu

Medtner Sonata Difficulty Ranking?

Reddit r/classicalmusic·u/ThatPineapple5757·6 months ago
#aQ8EHTbl
#pretty#seems#tricky#fingerwork#parallel
Reading 0:00
15s threshold

Maybe the composer is too niche to get helpful answers, but I have a hyperfixation on Medtner and my main goal as a pianist is to learn all of his and Scriabin's sonatas. I've learned the Op. 11 no. 2 in the past and I'm currently learning the rest of Op. 11. I'm trying to think of a general order in which to approach them.

My idea of a ranking would be

Op. 11 no 2

Op 38 no 1 reminiscanza, although if i included the entire opus i'd probably put it at 10

Op 56 Idyll

Op 11 no 3

Op 11 no 1 has a lot of tricky counterpoint and 3+4/3+2 polyrhythms, where the triplets are phrased in 2 rather in 3, making melodic phrasing pretty difficult to sound right.

8-9. Op 22. Nothing unmanageable but some occasional fast fingerwork in the right hand. Op 25 no 1 has some trills that have to be executed very quickly in the last movement. Also trilling parallel intervals/parallel thirds in general just suck

Op. 5.…

Continue reading — create a free account

Join HashtagPLUS to read full articles, follow hashtags, vote, and join the conversation.