An engineering case study comparing Codzee, Greptile, CodeRabbit, and CodeAnt across 435 lines of code, 6 files, and 26 seeded defects.
Every developer knows that writing code is only one part of software development.
The real challenge often begins when a pull request is opened.
A function might work perfectly in isolation but introduce unexpected behavior elsewhere. A database migration might contain valid SQL statements but create a production risk. A security vulnerability might exist even when the code looks completely normal.
This is why AI code review tools are becoming an important part of modern engineering workflows.
But an important question remains:
How well can AI code review tools actually understand a real codebase and identify defects that developers might overlook?
We decided to test this through a hands-on experiment involving four AI code review tools:
Codzee
Greptile
CodeRabbit
CodeAnt
All four tools received the same pull request, the same code changes, and the same testing…