Last week I published a test of 120 deleted Reddit posts against public archives. The short version: 51 of 120 came back with usable text , and every single one came from two subreddits.
This post is about the part nobody writes up β why recovery splits that way, and what it means if you're building anything on top of these archives.
The data
Subreddit 2021 2024
r/buildapc 14/15 (93%) 15/15 (100%)
r/homelab 10/15 (67%) 12/15 (80%)
r/AskReddit 0/15 0/15
r/pics 0/15 0/15
Total 24/60 (40%) 27/60 (45%)
Method: 15 posts per subreddit per year, taken from two single days (2021-06-01 and 2024-06-01), no hand-picking. A record counted as recovered only if the archive returned real text longer than a [deleted] / [removed] placeholder.
The counterintuitive part: age doesn't matter
2021 scored 40%. 2024 scored 45%. Two years apart, same result.
That kills the intuition that older posts are harder to recover.β¦