Menu

Arguments against overpopulation that are demonstrably wrong, part seven.“Humans are not yeast.”

Reading 0:00
15s threshold

Quick preamble: I want to highlight some arguments against overpopulation which I believe are demonstrably wrong. Many of these are common arguments which pop up in virtually every discussion about overpopulation. They are misunderstandings of the subject, or contain errors in reasoning, or both. It feels frustrating to encounter them over and over again.

This post is focused on arguments that dismiss overpopulation, and limits to human growth, as mistaken ideas that fail to account for human technology, innovation, and adaptability. This often starts with some true or at least partly true claims, such as:

Humans are not yeast (we certainly are not, but we do share a common ancestor)

Carrying capacity is not fixed

Humans can modify our environment

Humans are adaptable and innovative

Many predictions of resource shortages, famines, and catastrophes have failed to eventuate (e.g Malthus, Paul Ehrlich)

Technology and new discoveries unlock new reserves of resources, or sometimes allow us to swap one…

Continue reading — create a free account

Join HashtagPLUS to read full articles, follow hashtags, vote, and join the conversation.