With Week 8 officially in the books, we've reached the approximate halfway point of the 2026 NFL season. The weekly action has provided us with sample sizes to assess the 2026 NFL Draft class. Several rookies aren't meeting expectations thus far.
First-round picks are expected to immediately contribute . Having analyzed the top-32 selections weekly while tracking progress, many are struggling for different reasons. From injuries to questionable scheme fits and underperformers, not everything is going according to plan.
We've identified five first-round picks who have especially disappointed to date .
2026 NFL Draft: 5 Underperforming First-Round Rookies at Midway Point
Jeremiyah Love, RB, Arizona Cardinals
Jeremiyah Love's rookie season has been derailed by recurring ankle injuries that have caused him to miss multiple games. He was recently placed on IR, meaning more absences are coming.…