A smaller image file is useful. A smaller file that visibly damages a logo, screenshot, or photo is not always a win.
So instead of comparing marketing claims, I ran the same four source images through DigImg, TinyPNG, and ShortPixel. I downloaded each result, measured the actual output bytes, and calculated SSIM with the same scikit-image workflow used for DigImg's own measurements.
This is a small, reproducible spot check β not a universal ranking of image compressors. The goal is to show the trade-offs on four different image types.
Why measure bytes and quality together
A compression number on its own is easy to flatter. "Up to 80% smaller" can be true for one photo at one aggressive setting and misleading for everything else. File size tells you what you save; a quality metric tells you what you paid for it.β¦