Take a daily breakout strategy on gold that has been profitable for five years. Keep the exact moments it enters the market. Replace its direction with a coin flip. Keep its trade management. Run it 100 times with 100 different coins. All 100 runs are profitable, median profit factor 2.06, about half the profit of the original. Now keep the coin flip and remove the trade management. On real ticks, every single run loses.
That pair of results is what this article is about. A profitable breakout system turns out to be three separable things, when it trades, which way it trades, and how it handles the trade afterwards , and they do not contribute to the profit the way most of us assume.…