Member-only story
PoliticsFilmCultureSocietyPsychology Dave Chappelle Told the Same Joke. So Why Did the Outrage Change?
Maia Niguel Hoskin, Ph.D.
5 min read7 hours ago
Press enter or click to view image in full size
Apparently, a joke about a man’s death only becomes morally reprehensible when the right man is dead. At least, that’s the uncomfortable question Dave Chappelle’s latest controversy raises. When comedian Tony Hinchcliffe made a joke about George Floyd’s final breaths, some defended it as the nature of comedy.
But when Chappelle recycled nearly the identical punchline about Charlie Kirk, a different audience erupted in outrage. Same premise, same cruel punchline, but about a different man. Suddenly, America was having a very different conversation about comedy's limits.
During Netflix’s The Roast of Kevin Hart in May, Hinchcliffe joked that George Floyd was looking up from the afterlife, laughing so hard he couldn’t breathe. The reference was unmistakable.…