This post first ran on CrystlQuant .
On Sunday afternoon in Arlington, the Dallas Cowboys scored 40 points and lost. The San Francisco 49ers won 46-40, and the Cowboys walked off as members of one of the smallest clubs in football.
Forty points is supposed to settle it. Our tables hold 7,091 NFL regular-season games with a final score, from September 12, 1999 through the late-afternoon games of November 15, 2026. In those games a team scored 40 or more 741 times. It won 713 of them, 96.2%. It tied twice, and both ties came in the same game. It lost 26 times. Dallas on Sunday was number 26.
Why 40 almost never loses
An NFL team scores 23.0 points in an average game this season, through November 15, 2026. In 1999 it was 20.8. Forty is close to double a normal day. For a team that gets there to lose, the other side has to have its own extraordinary day in the same three hours, and finish ahead.
That has happened in 27 of the 7,091 games, about one in 263: 26 with a winner and one 40-40 tie.…