We built one simple stock score (equal weights on trend, stability, fundamentals and the market backdrop, plus news tone for the US) and tested it the same way in two markets: the S&P 100 and India's Nifty 50.
The setup
Development data 2020 to September 2025; the final 12 months sealed and opened exactly once after the score was frozen.
Label: each stock against its index over the next 20 trading days.
Measure: daily rank IC, the correlation between the score's ranking and what happened next.
The results
Market Development IC Sealed-year IC
US (S&P 100) +0.0085 (t 0.46) β0.0585 (t β2.47)
India (Nifty 50) +0.0187 (t 1.12) +0.0087 (t 0.21)
In the US the sealed year came out significantly negative : higher-scored stocks did worse. In India it was flat, indistinguishable from random rankings.
What to take from it
Neither market shows a usable ranking. India's numbers are not "better"; t 0.21 means nothing either way.
One market is not a replication.β¦