Does PNG-to-ICO transparency survive? A measured alpha test across 16–128 px
Yes. A transparent WebP source converted to ICO keeps alpha = 0 at all four corners at every size from 16 to 128 px. Below is the pixel-by-pixel proof.
The question
When you save an image as JPEG, the alpha channel is gone — JPEG has no transparency. If your icon source was a JPG, renaming the file extension to .ico does not bring alpha back; the pixel data simply doesn't contain it.
But if your source is a PNG or WebP with an alpha channel, does the ICO conversion preserve it? I ran a measurement to find out.
Source image
A 256×256 RGBA image: a red rounded rectangle with a yellow circle at the center. The exterior is fully transparent (alpha = 0).…