Pros
Easy to apply, thanks to extra-pointed tip
Opaque, strong color
Lasts for up to 12 hours
Cons
Can take a second to fully dry (so be careful for smudges)
Why we love it: In testing, this performed extremely well against the competition—specifically when head-to-head with much more expensive liquid eyeliners. The waterproof pen quickly draws precise lines in whatever color you choose, and it comes out opaque upon first press. The extra-fine tip also makes drawing wings a breeze, even if you’re a cat-eye newbie.
Type Brush-tip liquid
Shades 9
Waterproof? Yes
One Cosmo editor’s review: “This is the only liquid eyeliner I’ve touched for years. Why spend $$$ on something that performs as well, if not worse, than this $10 pick?…