An AI agent can give you the correct answer and still have done the wrong thing to get there.
It might skip a required tool, pass incorrect arguments, encounter an execution error, or reach the right answer by coincidence.
In a simple chatbot, evaluating the final response may be enough for a basic quality check. But once an agent starts interacting with tools, the final response tells only part of the story.
How do we know whether an agent actually completed a task correctly, followed the expected execution path, and handled tool failures appropriately?
I wanted to explore this problem by building a small evaluation framework for tool-using AI agents.
That project became Agent Reliability Lab .
The problem: A correct answer doesn't always mean a successful execution
Consider an agent asked to calculate:
Use the calculate tool to compute 125 * 8 + 37.
Enter fullscreen mode
Exit fullscreen mode
The expected answer is 1037 .
There are several ways an agent might respond:
It invokes the calculator…