Menu

Your Upload Preview Shows a Black Box: Handling 3GP, WMV, AVI and MTS Files That the Video Element Can't Play
📰

Your Upload Preview Shows a Black Box: Handling 3GP, WMV, AVI and MTS Files That the Video Element Can't Play

DEV Community: javascript·Nibbo·16 days ago
#ll5SLhih
#devtojavascript#devto#dev#file#upload
Reading 0:00
15s threshold

Nibbo

Posted on Oct 31

Edited on Oct 31

You build an upload form, add a nice preview with URL.createObjectURL(file) in a <video> tag, and test it with an MP4 from your phone. Works great. Then support tickets arrive: "the preview is black", "it says the file is broken", "the upload button never activates".

The file usually isn't broken. It is in a container or codec the browser simply does not decode. Here's how I deal with it.

What browsers actually play

Roughly, across current Chrome, Firefox and Safari:

Container Typical codecs Plays in <video> ?

MP4 H.264 + AAC Yes, everywhere

WebM VP8/VP9/AV1 + Opus Yes (Safari: recent versions)

MOV H.264/HEVC Often, HEVC depends on OS/hardware

MKV anything Chrome sometimes, Safari no

AVI, WMV, 3GP, MTS/M2TS, FLV DivX, WMV9, H.263, AMR, AC-3… Usually no

Old phones (3GP with AMR audio), Windows Movie Maker exports (WMV), camcorders (MTS/AVCHD) and screen recorders from 2010 (AVI) are exactly what non-technical users find in their archives.

Step 1: detect…

Continue reading — create a free account

Join HashtagPLUS to read full articles, follow hashtags, vote, and join the conversation.