Nine of the 10 votes cast at Wednesday’s Survivor 51 Tribal Council didn’t even count, and Danny “Kilby” Kilby went home on the one that did. The Ontario game designer was paired with Kristin Flickinger for the double elimination twist. Angelica “Jelly” Loblack ‘s hidden immunity idol canceled the eight votes against her and Devin Way , Cristian Chavez ‘s Shot in the Dark protected him and Carter Krull , and Devin’s lone vote sent Kilby and Kristin out together as the first two members of the jury.
Speaking with Men’s Journal the morning after the episode aired, Kilby said that extra vote Cristian gave to Eric was actually supposed to come to him, so he could play it on Maggie Nestor . When it went to Eric instead, he changed course. “I was like, ‘Oh my God, Cristian betrayed me.’ Are you joking? So I got all spooked.…