I wasn't paying the slightest bit of attention when Lucky told me who to deliver his present to today, so I went to my inventory to check. Except I clicked it out of instinct and opened it (and then had to go ask who to take it to because I STILL didn't see who it said).
I didn't want Lucky to be mad at me, so I decided to try a little experiment. Maybe the villagers won't care who wrapped it as long as it's wrapped? So I wrapped it in blue paper and hoped for the best. And it turns out, they really can't tell the difference! So nobody ever has to know I accidentally opened the present.