BrightEdge ran identical prompts across ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, and Google AI Mode. The three platforms disagreed on which brands to recommend 62% of the time. Only 17% of queries produced the same brand recommendations across all three.
If you are optimizing for "AI search" as if it is one thing, this data says it is at least three different things, and they contradict each other more often than they agree.
The data
BrightEdge published the study analyzing tens of thousands of identical prompts across the three platforms using their AI Catalyst tool.…