The scenes as Keir Starmer’s welfare plans fell apart in June 2025 were like something out of a James Graham play. In all the plotting and intrigue, the scorned and underestimated of Starmer’s backbenches rose up and ran rings around him. No playwright could have come up with a better plot about to where those characters ended up. One minister, poised to resign if Starmer didn’t back down, today sits around Andy Burnham’s cabinet table. Two of the chief rebels are now the de facto deputy prime minister and the chief whip, respectively. And the mayor who voiced his criticisms? He is Prime Minister.
Now the welfare bill – rising, unpopular and politically delicate – is their problem. But Burnham and his government have always agreed on the need to reform welfare. They just intend to do it very differently to how Starmer proposed.