Every broker delivers when nothing breaks. So compare them on the crash.
SQS = a take-a-number ticket. SNS = a group text. Kafka = a tape recorder. Redis Pub/Sub = live radio.
The grid
Kafka here means ordinary consumer groups. Share groups get their own section below.
Case SQS SNS Kafka Redis Pub/Sub
Who gets it Competing workers; standard can duplicate Every matching subscription Each subscribed group; one owner per partition Matching subscribers connected now
A worker dies Undeleted message becomes visible after timeout Retryable delivery failures get retries Resumes from committed offsets No replay
It keeps failing DLQ with a redrive policy Subscription DLQ for failed delivery, if configured Your code decides Nothing to retry
It arrives twice Standard can; FIFO deduplicates sends within its window and scope Standard can; FIFO deduplicates publishes within its window and scope Uncommitted work can repeat No redelivery; overlapping subscriptions can duplicate
Nobody listening Retained up to 14…