Some bad news for you, friends: Love Island USA fans think that season 8’s Aniya Harvey and Carl Schmidt may have called it quits—and while the two haven’t confirmed anything yet, I must say the evidence is pretty convincing.

The fandom first became suspicious after Aniya was asked about her relationship with Carl at the Victoria’s Secret Fashion Show on October 18 and gave a somewhat lukewarm response. “Me and Carl are good,” she told E! News. “We’re really just focused on our work right now and just building that up, so I’m just really happy to be here at Victoria’s Secret and just see the show.”

It’s giving...deflection.

Not long after, fans noticed (as captured by @meyechelgossips) that Kayda Bosse is seemingly no longer following Carl on Instagram...and neither is Aniya’s sister, Asia Harvey.

However!…