Credit: Lauren Gruber for Cosmopolitan

Smells like: Bergamot, almond, orris, pink pepper, vanilla, sandalwood, amber cream

One Cosmo editor says: “If you adore a smooth, woody vanilla scent (think Vanilla Skin from Phlur or Vanilla 28 from Kayali ), then there’s a good chance you’ll be into Vanilla Whip. It’s more complex than I expected, thanks to the sandalwood and powdery orris that balance out its sweet vanilla notes. I think this would be blind buy-safe for any vanilla fan.”—LAUREN GRUBER, COMMERCE EDITOR

Credit: Lauren Gruber for Cosmopolitan

Smells like: Strawberry, peach, mandarin, geranium, cocoa blanc, amber, vanilla, sandalwood

One Cosmo editor says: “Color me surprised: I don't really like fruity perfumes, but I kind of vibe with this, in that my 16-year-old-self would probably have EATEN THIS UP. Sure it's fruity and kind of smells like a Claire's or Limited Too, but in a way that feels super nostalgic.…