Earlier this week I reported that the "language-like" Zipf law found in humpback whale song (Arnon et al. 2025, Science 387:649) is matched by a simple second-order Markov chain. Three more pre-registered tests on the authors' own data have now come back, and together they trace the song's extra structure to its source: repetition.
What we found
result
Held-out test: whale song vs second-order chains -0.0490 vs -0.0783 bits per element, p = 0.005
Whale elements removed by collapsing repeats 0.6290 (second-order chains: 0.4982, p = 0.005)
Top-ten whale "words" that are repetition cells 35 of 80 (chains: 26.89, p = 0.005)
Held-out test after collapsing repeats -0.1454 vs -0.0955, p = 1.000, worse in all 8 years
Same test on English of the same size 5 of 5 detected, 0 of 5 false alarms
First , a held-out prediction test (does knowing more than the last two elements help predict unseen song?) finds structure in whale song that a second-order chain cannot reproduce.…