I asked for ₹12 LPA, the offer came in at ₹10.2 LPA. Same role, same scope. HR said "this is the best we can do" — but a friend in the same company told me offers there almost always have room.
What I'm planning to counter with: thank them, restate the researched range for the role (₹11–12.5 LPA for this city and experience), point to two proof lines from my resume (led a 4-person team, cut reporting time from 3 hours to 30 minutes with a dashboard I built), and ask for the full offer in writing — base vs CTC, joining bonus, first review date.
Two things I'm unsure about: is it true that the first number you hear is basically the ceiling, or do companies actually move 10–15% when you counter with proof? And does asking for a joining bonus or a notice-period buyout ever work, or does it just annoy HR?
Has anyone countered an offer like this and had it move? What did you actually say?