Low contrast text has been the most common accessibility failure on the web for as long as the WebAIM Million has measured it: in 2019 it was on 85.3% of the home pages of the top one million sites, and in 2026 it's on 83.9%. That's eight editions, and it came first in all eight.
It's hard to blame that on people not knowing. The rule is one number, a contrast ratio of 4.5 between normal-size text and its background for WCAG's AA level (3 for large text), and the same tools that run those surveys measure it on their own. I still built a palette generator that looked even and didn't meet it. This article is about why that happens.
What's been measured and what hasn't
In WebAIM's series, low contrast dropped four years in a row, from 86.4% in 2021 to 79.1% in 2025, and in 2026 it went back to 83.9%, with 34 instances per page on average, 15% more than the year before.…