"Third-party certified" is one of the most reassuring phrases on a supplement label. It sounds like an independent authority has checked the product and given it a pass. Often that is broadly true — but the phrase covers a wide range of very different arrangements, and the details matter more than the badge.
At its strongest, third-party certification means an independent laboratory tested a specific batch of the product against a published standard: identity of the ingredients, absence of specified contaminants, and sometimes dissolution or disintegration. The certifier's name and the standard should be identifiable, and the certificate should relate to the batch you are buying, not to a one-off test from years ago.
At its weakest, the phrase can mean a manufacturer paid for a single test of a single sample, or that a supplier's raw material was certified while the finished product never was.…