Two images come out of the same camera on the same day. One is a ceramic mug on a seamless backdrop. The other is a portrait lit with a softbox. Both are 1800×1200, both get upscaled 2× with the same preset, and both come back slightly wrong — in opposite directions. The mug looks like plastic. The face looks like a mannequin. Turning the strength slider up fixes neither, because the two failures are not the same defect at different intensities.
Product work and portrait work should not share a pipeline, and the reason is not "one needs more sharpening." The two source classes have different statistical structure, and a learned upscaler is a machine that exploits statistical structure.
The two sources are statistically opposite
A material surface — brushed aluminium, woven cotton, stone, cardboard — is stationary in the texture sense. The statistics of a 32×32 patch of the left side of the fabric are close to those of a 32×32 patch on the right.…