Ran the same London Reversal rules I posted last week (FTMO results above) over on Eightcap, same symbol, same period, same inputs. However numbers are way off. FTMO results are within 30-100% range, which Eightcap is in 300% over 34 months. Same as last week, I have uploaded my detailed results in PipEcho Strategy lab.
Best guess on why: different liquidity/feed between brokers. FTMO and Eightcap don’t source quotes from the same liquidity pool, so spreads, the exact wicks that trigger sweeps, and tick-level fill prices during London open all differ slightly — and this strategy’s edge depends on precise sweep/CISD timing, so small feed differences are enough to flip trades that were barely winners into losers. Good reminder that a backtest “working” is broker-feed-specific until you’ve cross-validated it.
Attaching screenshots from both Tests
submitted by