Menu

Why do students remember "two negatives make a positive" but still get (-3) × (-4) wrong?

Reddit r/learnmath·u/EmpathyMath·5 days ago
#tDXngn0l
#minus#pattern#students#negatives#article
Reading 0:00
15s threshold

I teach middle schoolers, and (-3) × (-4) is one of those topics where the rule is easy to say but hard to really get.
Most of my students can repeat "two negatives make a positive" perfectly. Then on the next quiz, they still write (-3) × (-4) = -12, or they get confused when it shows up as -3 × (-4) in a longer expression.
When I ask them what they think is happening, I usually hear two things:
"Minus times minus is plus, I just forgot."
"It's like a debt, but I don't really know why it flips."
The pattern explanation (3 × -4 = -12, 2 × -4 = -8, 1 × -4 = -4, 0 × -4 = 0, so -1 × -4 must be +4) helps some of them, but others just memorize the pattern and still get lost when there's a variable or a minus in front.
How do you teach this so it actually sticks? Do you use the number line, the pattern, debt / opposite, or something else?
I'm curious what actually worked in your classroom, not just what the textbook says.