Analysts open their earnings call questions with "congrats on the quarter" so often that it sounds like a reflex. I wanted to know whether it carries any information, so I read the analyst questions on 59,306 earnings calls held by 3,562 US-listed companies from 2020 to 2025, sorted every congratulation by what it was for, and lined the calls up against the stock's move against SPY.
The short answer
Analysts who praised the results Calls Median return vs SPY, to the next day's close Beat SPY
None (no congratulations at all) 35,833 -0.7% 44.3%
One 11,199 +1.0% 56.7%
Two 4,206 +1.7% 60.4%
Three or more 2,961 +2.6% 64.6%
The pleasantry is informative, up to a point. When several analysts praise the results, the stock has usually moved the same way. It is not a forecast.
Five findings
1. On most calls, nobody says it. On 60.4% of calls not one analyst congratulated anybody. Counting each analyst once per call, 12.7% of the 351,985 analysts congratulated someone at the start of a question.…