A lawyer can argue with a judge, challenge an order, and even criticise how a case is being heard. But there is a line between disagreeing with a court and bringing its functioning to a halt. Crossing that line can expose an advocate to contempt proceedings, a fine or imprisonment. It can also lead to separate criminal action and disciplinary proceedings that may affect the lawyer’s right to practise.
The issue came into focus after lawyers allegedly vandalised an Allahabad High Court courtroom, assaulted court staff and government advocates, and disrupted proceedings on October 28. A day later, a bench of Justices Ajay Bhanot and Divesh Chandra Samant recommended criminal contempt proceedings and asked the Chief Justice to consider registering FIRs.…