Nick Martinez may not be among the highly discussed free agent options for the Mets this offseason, but he's coming off one of the best seasons of his career and could fit the profile David Stearns is looking for in the rotation. Martinez posted a 3.10 ERA in 180 innings in 2026 and a 2.81 ERA in the playoffs.
Spotrac projects his market value at 2 years, $42.68 million, a significant AAV, but a short-term commitment. Even if the Mets acquire Tarik Skubal or another ace-level option, an additional proven starter would greatly help a young rotation.
That said, Martinez is unique among the other free agent starters. His ceiling is high, as proven in 2026, but there's a good amount of risk in investing in his future, making it all the more important to analyze his pros and cons.
Pro #1- Proven bullpen experience
If the Mets want to have success in the postseason, they need a starter who can be utilized in the bullpen. It's very difficult to win in October strictly using your relievers.…