Menu

CMV: The soul doesn't exist, and one day we're going to make a case for it with body replacement technology.

Reddit r/changemyview·u/ZXCChort·7 months ago
#x42F6Ite
#soul#body#replace#every#technology
Reading 0:00
15s threshold

We are already replacing parts of a human body. We've been doing it for decades: hip joints, knee caps, heart valves, and nobody bats an eye. More recently we've started growing organs in labs, printing skin, implanting neural interfaces. The direction is obvious and it is picking up speed.

So let me take you through a thought experiment that, to me, destroys the idea of a soul completely.

We are able to replace a leg with a prosthetic leg now and you're still you. Replace your kidney with an artificial one: still you. Replace your heart with a mechanical pump, and you're still you. No one would seriously argue that you lost some soul after getting a new knee.

Now extend this forward. In 50, 100, maybe 200 years we will almost surely be able to replace bones with synthetic ones. Swap out blood for some engineered oxygen carrier. Grow new skin. Replace every organ of the body one by one. At each single step the individual is still undeniably themselves.…

Continue reading — create a free account

Join HashtagPLUS to read full articles, follow hashtags, vote, and join the conversation.