C S Karnan, a former High Court judge who accused colleagues of caste discrimination and was sentenced to six months in prison for criminal contempt while still on the bench, died in Chennai on Friday. He was 71.
Justice Karnan’s confrontations with fellow judges unfolded as India’s judiciary faced questions on how it chose its members, how it assessed merit, and how much of that process it was willing to explain. He brought caste into those disputes with an insistence that drew attention to who sat on the bench and how Dalit lawyers and judges were treated.
His own conduct came under scrutiny, too, first from colleagues who accused him of indiscipline and later from lawyers who complained that his public statements threatened and demeaned women.
From a Tamil Nadu village to High Court
Born on June 12, 1955, Karnan came from Karnatham, a village in Tamil Nadu’s Cuddalore district.…