The Play Console error "Your Android App Bundle is signed with the wrong key" means the file you uploaded was signed with a different upload key than the one Google has on record for this app. The fix is to sign the bundle with the original keystore. If that keystore is lost, you can request an upload key reset in Play Console and keep the same app.
The full message usually goes on to show two SHA-1 fingerprints: the certificate your bundle is expected to be signed with, and the certificate that signed the file you uploaded. Those two lines are the whole diagnosis, so don't close the dialog before you copy them.
Upload key and app signing key: what the error is about
With Play App Signing there are two keys. Google's help page describes the upload key as the one you use to sign your app bundle before uploading it, which Google uses to verify your identity. The app signing key is the one Google uses to sign the final APKs delivered to users' devices.
The wrong key error is about the upload key.…