Menu

Maxwell v. Dinis: surprise, it's actually just another Bivens case!

Reddit r/supremecourt·u/popiku2345·12 days ago
#zoaDezkQ
#bivens#habeas#maxwell#circuit#confinement
Reading 0:00
15s threshold

TL;DR : the fifth circuit says "this isn't a habeas case, try Bivens." The prisoner disagrees. The federal government disagrees. SCOTUS appoints someone to defend the fifth circuit's opinion -- he also disagrees. Somewhere, the ghost of Bivens is wondering why anyone is still talking about it.

Tomorrow, SCOTUS hears oral argument in Maxwell v. Dinis. Nominally, the case is about whether federal prisoners can use habeas to challenge the denial of earned time credits under the First Step Act so that they can move to home confinement rather than prison. The formal QP:

Whether a claim regarding application of time credits under the First Step Act of 2018 seeking accelerated transfer to a halfway house or home confinement, can be brought in a habeas petition under 28 U.S.C. § 2241.

The case background

William Maxwell is serving a 20-year sentence in prison for racketeering, conspiracy, and other related non-violent offenses.…

Continue reading — create a free account

Join HashtagPLUS to read full articles, follow hashtags, vote, and join the conversation.