I'm going with fixed because it's cheaper to replace when I fuck something up. I'm hobbyist who spends 90% of time on MIG, learning TIG, occasional plasma cutting, almost all steel. So switching lenses when I do a different process or material is not a huge deal.
Here's the machines, the amp range,. and the shade range the intertubes have suggested.
| Machine | Amperage | Reco'd Shade |
| MIG Millermatic 211 | 30-120 | 10-13 |
| TIG Invertig 221 | 50-220 | 8-13 |
| Lincoln Pro-Cut 55 | 25-60 | 8-12 |
So with a 2X4 fixed lens, it looks like the starter set would be a #9 and a #12? It's difficult seeing my puddle sometimes FWIW.