I’ve been lurking on this sub for years & know y’all will be able to flag something that multiple roofers haven’t been able to figure out.

I bought this house about a year ago. We flagged a leak before closing. It was supposedly repaired, but then it leaked again, and they came back to’ ‘fix’ again. After the third time they came back to attempt repair, we had separate roofers come out to identify an issue and suggest a permanent fix to stop the leak.

The original work was under warranty (which coincidentally expired exactly today).

Multiple roofers have proposed deleting the feature and going flat, which my wife would not stand for.

They’re telling me that they can’t find a specific source of the leak, and it’s likely coming through the metal and that the metal has worn out and needs to be replaced and is not worth repairing.

I flew my drone up there to take some photos today so I could take a look for myself.

The metal doesn’t look that bad to me & I suspect that the intrusion is happening where the…